CreateDebate


Debate Info

11
18
Yes, I think so. No, I don't think so.
Debate Score:29
Arguments:28
Total Votes:30
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes, I think so. (11)
 
 No, I don't think so. (17)

Debate Creator

steffsplm(18) pic



Multimedia (like iPads) are beneficiary and relevant and should be adopted by all schools.

The use of multimedia tools (like iPads) at schools is the new way of education. In the Netherlands new schools have risen under the name of Steve Jobs schools. The key characteristics of these schools are the use of multimedia such as the iPad in cooperation with traditional educational methods. The focus of the schools is more on the individual development of students. There are no teachers, but coaches, who try to find the talents and passions of each individual student. Educational programs, apps, games, and social platforms are available 24/7. 

Yes, I think so.

Side Score: 11
VS.

No, I don't think so.

Side Score: 18
1 point

Yes I do agree, it is the future, using one device for all of our work. Depending on what materials are used to make these devices, it can also be great for the environment, less books! Less trees cut down etc. !

Side: Yes, I think so.
1 point

I think that's a fair point your making, Paul! If the tools and the resources are there, why not make use of them? So from a ecological point of view it's a good idea. How about the educational point of view? Do you think students will reach the same amount of professional schooling, or will they slack off being distracted all of the time(which was mentioned earlier by a commenter)? Please elaborate :)

Side: Yes, I think so.
1 point

Yes ipads (or laptops) should definitely be adopted by MORE schools. I remember how all those stupid, heavy books destroyed my back! The health of students should definitely be taken into account. It is also better for the environment; all those books use a TREMENDOUS amount of paper! of course, huge factories aren't exactly good for the environment either, but there will be ipad factories anyway and I think it would be better than destroying thousands of trees.

I also think it is more educational. iPads are more interactive. Apps can be used to engage the student and they will understand everything better.

Side: Yes, I think so.
1 point

Multimedia is ofcourse beneficiary and relevant! Even in school. It is a great tool to facilitate and develop a community of learners through online ice-breaker activities. These activities will offer fun and easy ways to get to know each other while also providing outlets for student creativity. Especiially the first couple of lessons this is usefull. Furthermore it can help students visualize difficult concepts or procedures more easily by using static or dynamic multimedia. There are loads of usefull software online, which enables you to get your message across in a better way. And my final pro reason is that it encourages collaboration and feedback by integrating assignments with tools that support conversations and comments.

Side: Yes, I think so.

Every child is different and has different needs, also when it comes to education. With the help of e.g. ipads the learning method can be adapted and fitted to the needs of every child. A smart kid will learn faster and a someone les bright will get a bit more attention/time needed. So in my opinion this development is a positive one that can only benefit children.

Side: Yes, I think so.
1 point

Today's generation can't be confined to just text books in fact in schools like American International School Chennai provides an atmosphere for students to experience what really is like learning with electronics . Schemes like BYOT that is bring your own technology for grades 6 to 12 is just awesome plus with a Wi-Fi campus who would not want to surf internet.

Supporting Evidence: awesome school regret switching school. (www.aisch.org)
Side: Yes, I think so.

As long as the parents are willing to purchase the iPads for their children, then I say full speed ahead.

Side: Yes, I think so.
0 points

I agree, because i think ipads are "the books" of the future.

Side: Yes, I think so.
2 points

I believe that schools - especially primary schools - should not make use of these multimedia tools, because I think that this could lead to the children lacking in other abilities. Things such as writing skills and math skills. By implementing iPads in classrooms, children will slack off by using a spelling checkers, calculators and other apps that help them complete their tasks.

I also believe that children should not be pushed to develop a talent on such an early age in the so-called Steve Jobs schools. I think that this will lead to them feeling a lot of pressure.

Side: No, I don't think so.
steffsplm(18) Disputed
1 point

If by lacking skills such as writing and doing math, you mean the loss of authenticity in schooling, then I heartily agree with you, Sudi! However I think that apart from being a whole new way of education, that schools like Steve Jobs schools also are a collaboration with traditional education. I assume writing will still be learned using pen and paper, but that the iPad comes into action for educational apps, learning games, as a portfolio, and as a social platform. There are countless of possibilities all stored into one single device.

Could you elaborate a little bit on what you mean by 'multimedia tools could lead to children lacking in other abilities'?

As to your comment of slacking off, I think this is already an unstoppable truth. How many kids these days walk around with smartphones in their pockets?

Lastly, I am not sure if 'pushing children into developing a talent' is what is done on these schools. I believe it's merely a coaching, recognizing the student's own capabilities and stimulating and supporting them. I don't know exactly how this comes to practice, but this sounds like a perfect way to stimulate a student into becoming what they personally want to be.

Side: Yes, I think so.
1 point

Because going to school is not only about finding talent and passion, this also could done outside of school. Schools are there to learn not to find passion etc.

Side: No, I don't think so.
koenoosterbr(25) Disputed
1 point

I disagree. Schools exist to support you in your personal development; finding out what the children's ambitions/passions are is part of this. However, I don't think this is the topic of the debate. In regard to the topic, Yes multimedia (like iPads) are beneficiary and relevant to schools, but No they 'should' not be adopted by all schools, all schools ought to have freedom to decide for themselves whether or not to pursue technological trends. If I were to have kids one day I'd like them to receive adequate and appropriate guidance and mental stimulation in the first place, and the tools used in that pursuit come secondary. I'd prefer one that hops onto modern trends such, but should a school chose to go old-skool and use books only then that's up to them. Therefore I disagree, it 'should' not be adopted by all schools. (offtopic: I'm not Jewish or Turkish, but these icons appear next to my name. Strange)

Side: Yes, I think so.
1 point

I think having social contact with teachers is a condition for learning. I think learning is not only with your brain, but also with your heart, that's why I think teachers are required.

Side: No, I don't think so.
steffsplm(18) Disputed
1 point

Thanks for your reply, Dieke! On the Steve Jobs schools there are indeed no teachers. The teaching is done on the technology made available, like the iPad. I do agree with you that children should have social contact and interaction with their teachers and fellow students. On the Steve Jobs schools students are provided with coaches, who help them achieve goals and find their passions and interests. I think it's different than the interaction one would have with a teacher, who is traditionally there to make sure a student studies the right amount of materials and does things on the time they need to be done. In my opinion, coaching seems like a better form of interaction with regard to the personal development of a student. Do you care to share one has your preference?

Side: Yes, I think so.
1 point

I think having social contact with teachers is a condition for learning. I think learning is not only with your brain, but also with your heart, that's why I think teachers are required.

Side: No, I don't think so.
1 point

I have mixed feelings about this. On one hand, I don't believe that multimedia is very beneficial, because kids learn about the world best through human interaction. Schools are there not only to teach them math and so on, but to teach them about 'life' and how to cope in situations. When this human interaction is minimized, will they learn enough?

On the other world, these multimedia are the future and it is not likely they are going away. They are certainly relevant and by using them for education, children will learn how to use them as well as develop new ideas (as their perception is different) on how to harness them in different manners.

Side: No, I don't think so.
1 point

I actually think that we should go back to less media. I have the feeling that all the technology takes away creativity. Why buy an expensive iPad to draw on, when you can just use pen and paper, which even leads to better quality. Also the availability of media does not let us think anymore. We get everything too much and too fast, let the students at least learn some of the old ways which will help them enhance their real talents.

Side: No, I don't think so.
1 point

I do not agree completely with this statement, even though I think it could be a good add option to todays schoolsystems I think the old fashion way works best. With a teacher in front of the class and a worldmap hanging on the wall. Technology serves our daily lives, but being completely dependable upon this media can hold back in the development of the (little) students. Especially for little kids, these kids are already required to be perfect when they enter elementary school; elementary school which means at the age of 4 years old! Making this possible cannot be done by a piece of metal. They need an example from another human and guidance, social contact with other kids and get their hands dirty. A computer only visualises something but it cannot give the feel of a real object or material. I sure think with the smart little gamer (little) students can have benefit from some of the aspects, like little calculating games or brain trigger games, but being completely dependent from this technology I strongly disagree!

Side: No, I don't think so.
1 point

Yes and No. But more "No" for me. Nowadays children are getting too addicted to the new technologies which cause a lot of problems in upbringing them. Also, children spend less time outdoors which might cause child obesity. They already have an access to the iPads, computers and other devices at their homes. I think there is no need to add these devices at the schools. Maybe it's a good idea to have a specialized class for this but not changing the whole education system.

From another side, it will save up a lot of money. Parents won't need to buy books. Plus, it will give good experience to the children and might help out in work with technologies and devices in future.

Side: No, I don't think so.
1 point

Although I firmly believe in the shift towards digital communication and also ultilising it for education, there is a border that should not be crossed. I think that elementary schools should stick to their traditional ways of teaching, simply because these basics are too important for the development of the children. However, learning them at a young age how to safely use Ipads and such, is not a bad idea. But the balance needs to be found.

Side: No, I don't think so.
1 point

It will probably be too tempting to go on social media during class. Also staring at an iPad will not help increase social interaction in class.

Side: No, I don't think so.
1 point

I disagree, because for a couple years my high school experimented with a setting that encouraged use of computers for everything and had no homework, and after a while I realised that it just encouraged laziness and did not teach discipline at all.

I was just playing games and surfing the internet every time I thought people wasn't looking and in hindsight, I really regretted the lack of structure when I went through regular high school later on and had all sorts of attitude related study problems.

It's a fun gimmick, sure, but looking at how overly attached people already are to their smartphones and how difficult it would be to really prevent people from only using multimedia for their intended purpose (there's always a way around everything), I don't think it's a good idea at all.

Books might be heavy, yes, but iPads and other multimedia devices can crash or break, servers can go offline and data can become corrupt, both on servers and on local storage media, and what are you going to do then, if disaster strikes?

Side: No, I don't think so.
1 point

No i think this idea of replacing teachers with technology and coaches is a horrible idea and can severely harm the development of a child's personality. Simply assisting them and only letting them use technology is not a suitable method to teach a school. The essence of a school is to guide and teach them, not to assist them. Especially in a young age children need to have a leading personality. I do not dislike the idea of using Ipads at school at general but they don't have to be adopted by all schools. Human teachers should still be the real teachers at school.

Side: No, I don't think so.
1 point

Multimedia tools can be beneficiary and are relevant, but not for everyone, not always and not at all schools. They can be used sometimes, but I think schools should be able to choose and parents should be able to choose schools accordingly. Furthermore, not all skills can be learned using iPads.

Side: No, I don't think so.
1 point

As futuristic as it may be, I believe iPads should not really be an option to educating children. First of all, there is a lack of interaction with the other students and I don't think interacting while playing a network game is a solution. We can't have the world turn too technological and I strongly believe children should be educated to 'find themselves' while playing with each other, experiencing the outer world and not be confined to using games and apps on a piece of technology.

I really think this will drive them to be too egotistical with no empathy for the others, but only for themselves. Because of its addictive nature, children will be too drawn to the iPad and forget that there are others around them to communicate with. I don't know if this is an effective way of spending their energy.

But I do believe this: they should make use of iPads among other things. To a certain extent they need to be introduced to it, yet the iPad shouldn't be a way of educating children.

Side: No, I don't think so.
1 point

I think that children should get personal attention. A teacher is able to see if a pupil is doing alright or not. And can determine what kind of eduation and guidance the pupil will need. Thereby Multimedia is full of entertainment (games, social media etc.) which will make it easier pupil to get distracted, which will decrease their motivation for school.

Side: No, I don't think so.
1 point

It is very important that children develop their writing skills because children nowadays are growing up already with many multimedia things like ipads and computers. If they implement the use of multimedia on schools, these child can't even write anymore normal. Some of these child don't even play on the streets because they are used to game on the computer or ipads instead of playing outside with friends. So my opinion related to this statement is that it not should be allowed, for a child it is good to develop their reading, writing skills with a pen and paper and not via computers and ipads.

Side: No, I don't think so.
1 point

When it comes to using it for teaching, I don't think the advantages of iPads outweigh the shortcomings. When it come to little kids, I think the traditional methods work best. They should practice their social skills, increase their attention span and be able to focus. The iPad can isolate you, especially at an age where you can't restrain yourself and it will distract the pupil from what is important. Maybe using the iPad for non-academic purposes will help them become familiar with technology, without creating distractions.

Side: No, I don't think so.