CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:71
Arguments:69
Total Votes:80
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 So under Democrat logic, the Nazi's were compassionate because they helped poor Germans. (64)

Debate Creator

Cuaroc(8829) pic



So under Democrat logic, the Nazi's were compassionate because they helped poor Germans.

I keep hearing people on the Left telling me how the Democrat party is more compassionate then Repubicans when it comes to helping the poor. So I ask you what on earth do you call compassion? For myself, I call compassion helping all people no matter their age or location. By location I mean in or out of the womb, as if traveling down the birth canal magically changes the Baby into a living growing human life.

One could try and make the ludicrous argument that Nazi's were compassionate people because they helped poor Germans. You first must turn off your brain and forget that those same compassionate Nazi's supported killing Jews.

So tell me how this is any different then Democrats claiming their party is more compassionate because they supposedly care more for the poor with our money, while supporting killing unborn Babies right up to birth. Spare me 1st trimester arguments when the Democrat party supports nine states with "no limit" abortions.

Obviously the GOP who supports protecting all innocent life is much more compassionate then Democrats. The GOP believes in a safety net for all helpless people no matter their age or location.
-FromWithin
Original Debate: http://www.createdebate.com/debate/show/So_under_Democrat_logic_the_Nazi_s_were_compassionate_because_they_helped_poor_Germans
Add New Argument
2 points

Anyone else notice that the first sentence had absolutely nothing to do with the rest of his rant?

The reason people think the Democrats are more compassionate toward poor people is because when they talk about helping poor people they actually mention poor people. Helping fetuses does not mean you help poor people.

2 points

Here we go. I will try and take this comparison seriously:

In Nazi Germany there was incredible compassion to those Germans that fit the party philosophy. They were very cruel to the jews and other minority groups.

The democrats are compassionate to every born human being. They are cruel to feotuses.

I care more about the Jews than about feotuses so I would support the Democrats over the Nazis.

Atrag(5666) Clarified
1 point

Ohh for fucks sake Cauroc i thought this was the original debate again. Cant you stop being such a pathetic sad act already?

1 point

Why didn't you go to the original debate then?

1 point

Here we go. I will try and take this comparison seriously:

In Nazi Germany there was incredible compassion to those Germans that fit the party philosophy. They were very cruel to the jews and other minority groups.

The democrats are compassionate to every born human being. They are cruel to feotuses.

I care more about the Jews than about feotuses so I would support the Democrats over the Nazis.

In Nazi Germany there was incredible compassion to those natural born Germans that paid the price for the party philosophy. They were very cruel to the Jews and other minority groups.

Cartman(18192) Disputed
1 point

What exactly were you trying to point out here?

FromWithin(8241) Disputed
-3 points
Hellno(17753) Disputed
2 points

Everyone probably just assumes they're banned from your debates or at least they will be after a post or two. Pathetic.

1 point

You've banned him in the past, so why would he?

You don't even remember the people you've pissed off, which is pretty funny.

1 point

Try not banning almost everyone you disagree with and you might get people posting on your original debates.

My god his shtick is getting boring.

I do enjoy how he compares people he disagrees with to Nazis whilst simultaneously complaining that people are insulting him.

1 point

"Those Nazis on the left keep calling us bigots and homophobes"

Classic.

It's downright scary to think that people can actually say that sort of thing and not understand why it's so ridiculous.

1 point

Obviously, you don't understand democratic logic, Neither do you understand the lessons Jesus, allegedly, taught (democrats DO). I think your problem is even more with an understanding of the word "LOGIC", than what group it is used in relation too.