CreateDebate


Debate Info

11
8
Yeah Nahh
Debate Score:19
Arguments:20
Total Votes:21
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yeah (9)
 
 Nahh (7)

Debate Creator

excon(12352) pic



Do Jews look alike?

Yeah

Side Score: 11
VS.

Nahh

Side Score: 8
2 points

They look like PEOPLE to me. Some are dark, some are light (even white??). Some have a significant nose or an odd "cap" on their head, even a big ol' hat and beard, but, yeah, they look like people to me.

Side: Yeah
1 point

Do Jews look alike?

Hello,

Here's a nice Jewish boy on CNN who LOOKS Jewish.. No?

https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/ 2018/12/13/cnn harryentennotthetimefordemocratstonominateawhitemanin2020.html

excon

Side: Yeah

Jews look alike. Part Jews look different. Africans look similar. When an African mates with a white woman, you get a man who has brown skin.

Same exact logic.

The question really is, what did Israel himself and his wife look like, seeing they are the grandparents of all Jews.

Maybe they were both white. Maybe he was white or brown, and she was black. We'll never know. But nom knows everything, so ask him. He was there.

Side: Nahh
excon(12352) Disputed
1 point

The question really is, what did Israel himself and his wife look like, seeing they are the grandparents of all Jews.

Hello bront:

Are you talking about Jacob??? DUDE! That's 6 fucking thousand YEARS ago.

What did Jesus look like??? DUDE!!!

excon

Side: Yeah
1 point

Doesn't matter what Jesus looked like if he had no kids. Jacob is who decides what a full blood Jew looks like.

Side: Nahh
1 point

Jews look alike.

We should bear in mind that when we disagree with this idiot about pretty much anything related to Jews, he calls us anti-Semites. Obviously the comment above proves who the anti-Semite is.

Side: Yeah
1 point

Nah. You're antisemites because there's no way in hell you'll condemn Muslim antisemites or ever take Israel's side on any issue because you prefer Arabs who hate Jews openly over Jews themselves. Or were you going to condemn Louis Farrakhan and Ilhan Omar now? I didn't think so. You'll be leaving those who hate Jews alone. Right buddy? Why is that buddy?

Side: Nahh
1 point

Obvisously not. Hereditary Judaism is passed on the mother side, the father doesn't have to be Jewish.

Side: Nahh
excon(12352) Clarified
1 point

Hereditary Judaism is passed on the mother side, the father doesn't have to be Jewish.

Hello again, BO:

What you say is true.. If, over 35 centuries, Jewish men kept on marrying gentile women, the gene pool would be diluted and my question would be folly..

However, consider for a minute, that over those 35 centuries, for the most part, Jews married Jews. We have a very closed knit community.. Venturing out was the exception, not the norm.. Truly, it's only been since WW II that most Jews even MET gentiles.

Hence, I suggest Jews DO have a look. I look Jewish.. People KNOW I'm a Jew LONG before I tell them..

excon

Side: Yeah
1 point

Obvisously not. Hereditary Judaism is passed on the mother side, the father doesn't have to be Jewish.

Obviously "Hereditary Judaism" is a pernicious and stupid myth, because Judaism is a religion which has nothing to do with ancestry.

There's this thing smart people sometimes use. It's called science. Now I know this is new territory for you, and it probably seems a bit strange when juxtaposed against your junk Bible science:-

The Myth of the Jewish Race: A Biologist's Point of View

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Myth-Jewish-Race-Biologists-Point/dp/0934223793

Side: Yeah
BigOats(1341) Disputed
1 point

Biologists have noe say in this matter at all. According to Judaism, you are a Jew if your mother is a Jew, regardless of whether or not you belong to the Judaic faith.

Side: Nahh