CreateDebate


Debate Info

12
21
The Left Is Honest Nah. Check Out My Lies.
Debate Score:33
Arguments:41
Total Votes:41
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 The Left Is Honest (11)
 
 Nah. Check Out My Lies. (19)

Debate Creator

Nomenclature(1257) pic



The Difference Between Left And Right Is As Simple As This: Honesty

I am personally terrified by this observation. Politics has literally become divided between soppy intellectuals and revisionist liars. You can see the divide on this very site. Of all the posters here who promote right wing politics, not a single one of them is intellectually honest.

Don't get me wrong. I'm not saying there are no liars on the left. It's more that I'm saying it isn't a prerequisite. Most on the left either want to be or already are intellectuals. Intellectualism is not a general pursuit of liars.

The Left Is Honest

Side Score: 12
VS.

Nah. Check Out My Lies.

Side Score: 21
0 points

Yeah, I'm sure there are plenty of people on the right who think the exact same thing about leftists.

I'm not going to accuse anyone of being dishonest because I have honestly been on both sides of the fence.

Your problem is that you presume that you are correct, and are uncharitable towards those who you see as being obviously wrong.

Oh yeah, there was even a time when I though that there was no way an honest person could be a Christian. Yeah, I was wrong.

I don't think those on the right really get just how hard/damn near impossible it is for someone who is poor, uneducated, and physically disabled to lift themselves out of poverty. They seem really insensitive towards those who are incapable of making it on their own. They don't lift a finger to help either. I don't think most people on the left realize that most of the policies they buy into are concocted by people who are intentionally trying to overthrow the government.

The problem with people on the left? People on the right?

They can all be selfish and uncharitable.

"Behold, a king shall reign in righteousness,

and princes shall rule in judgment.

And a man shall be as an hiding place from the wind,

and a covert from the tempest;

as rivers of water in a dry place,

as the shadow of a great rock in a weary land.

And the eyes of them that see shall not be dim,

and the ears of them that hear shall hearken.

The heart also of the rash shall understand knowledge,

and the tongue of the stammerers shall be ready to speak plainly.

The vile person shall be no more called liberal,

nor the churl said to be bountiful.

For the vile person will speak villany,

and his heart will work iniquity,

to practise hypocrisy, and to utter error against the Lord,

to make empty the soul of the hungry,

and he will cause the drink of the thirsty to fail.

The instruments also of the churl are evil:

he deviseth wicked devices to destroy the poor with lying words,

even when the needy speaketh right.

But the liberal deviseth liberal things;

and by liberal things shall he stand."

Side: The Left Is Honest
Rusticus(809) Disputed
2 points

@ TzarPepe - And here comes the Easter Bunny hippity hoppity hopping down the trail!

Side: The Left Is Honest
TzarPepe(763) Clarified
1 point

I suppose this is your example of leftist integrity.

Good show.

Side: The Left Is Honest
1 point

Your problem is that you presume that you are correct

Your problem is that you are completely full of shit. For three weeks you argued that a mistake in a dictionary proves the existence of God. You've got some nerve to be criticising other people, and especially without disproving what they have said.

Side: Nah. Check Out My Lies.
TzarPepe(763) Clarified
1 point

You are seriously only proving my point.

Not an ounce of charity in ya, is there?

Side: The Left Is Honest
TzarPepe(763) Clarified
1 point

You are the one claiming that people who don't agree with you are dishonest.

See, I could say you are dishonest. You look dishonest to me. I could also say you're an idiot. You look like an idiot to me.

However, maturity has taught me one thing. It isn't wise to lean on one's own understanding. I don't know. I'm not going to operate under the assumption that you are dishonest or an idiot. Why? Because nothing good can come out of that, and I don't know. I am wrong about a lot of things. I can say that because I am HONEST. Honest people know they are wrong about a lot of things.

See, I'd rather communicate as equals. Look at you, acting all high and mighty. What are you even standing on?

Your claim is that the difference between the left and the right is honesty, and that the right is dishonest.

This is why you'd be better off turning to God. IF you listened to God, you'd know that you are taking yourself as being the judge of good and evil. Right and wrong. True and false. The rightful judge of these things is God.

See, the thing you don't get is that there was no mistake in the dictionary. The Supreme and Ultimate Reality is my God. You do not know my God. If you knew my God, you would not deny God. You would turn to God and be healed.

Repent, turn away from your error and believe the good news! The Truth is what saves.

Side: The Left Is Honest
1 point

You've got some nerve to be criticising other people

Says the fraud with 50 puppet accounts, many who have dialogue on this very debate.

Side: The Left Is Honest
1 point

Your problem is that you are completely full of shit Nomenclature. For several days you argued that libs weren't intentionally discriminating against Asians. You've got some nerve to be criticising other people, and especially without disproving what they have said.

You claimed there was a left wing conspiracy to keep Asian kids out of American colleges. -Nomenclature

And gave 2 links.

One from CNN-

http://www.cnn.com/2017/08/03/opinions/liberals-affirmative-action-asian-factor-bauerlein/index.html

And the New York Times--

https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/08/02/us/affirmative-action-battle-has-a-new-focus-asian-americans.html

You debunked neither, and if you had, you'd be proving leftist media is a fraud.

Side: The Left Is Honest
1 point

Oh yeah, there was even a time when I though that there was no way an honest person could be a Christian. Yeah, I was wrong.

You weren't wrong. You are simply lying to try to convert people to your mad cult of nitwits. The truth is that you are obsessed with the Bible, with Christianity and with God and have been since early childhood. Madness like yours does not happen overnight. It is the result of cramming bullshit into your head for decades.

Side: Nah. Check Out My Lies.
TzarPepe(763) Clarified
1 point

It's about spreading the good news.

It's very simple.

The Truth is what sets you free.

You are too smart to grasp something so simple.

Side: The Left Is Honest
1 point

The truth is that you are obsessed with Progressivism, with Marxism and with government acting as "God" and have been since early childhood. Madness like yours does not happen overnight. It is the result of cramming bullshit into your head for decades.

Side: The Left Is Honest
2 points

Though some on this site continue to smear me as a liberal the truth is I am independent and moderate, and as such I find it hard to trust the honesty of anyone who trumpets a left or right ideology. The moment you try to fit every plan and every explanation into a neat simple package is the moment you start lieing to yourself and others in your quest to make it all fit.

To me the difference in the left and right isn't the presence of lieing, it's the quantity and audacity of the lies. There has never been a President (or politician) in US history who has racked up the lieing record of Trump. And yet the right just backs him up and rolls with it.

Side: Nah. Check Out My Lies.
1 point

Though some on this site continue to smear me as a liberal the truth is I am independent and moderate, and as such I find it hard to trust the honesty of anyone who trumpets a left or right ideology.

I think you are making an absolutely classic mistake which I have on occasion made myself. You presume that, since there are two sides, these sides must be equal.

Side: The Left Is Honest
Grenache(6053) Disputed
1 point

No. I'm saying I trust people who don't have blinders on. It doesn't matter whether one side's blinders are thicker than the other's or not, they're still blinders.

Side: Nah. Check Out My Lies.
2 points

@Nomenclature

The Difference Between Left And Right Is As Simple As This: Honesty

Wrong, and way overly simplistic (as usual)

Side: Nah. Check Out My Lies.

It's true. The left is known for dishonesty, cover ups, and blatant media monopolies who spread constant propaganda on mainstream outlets.

Side: Nah. Check Out My Lies.
1 point

It's true. The left is known for dishonesty, cover ups, and blatant media monopolies who spread constant propaganda on mainstream outlets.

It's OK guys. I'm fairly fluent in bronto double-speak.

Translation: It's false. The right is unknown for honesty, uncover downs and surreptitious anti-media communism which contract sporadic news under fringe inlets.

Side: The Left Is Honest
1 point

The right is unknown for honesty

Uh huh. We were so dishonest that we took away the left's slaves and abolished Jim Crow.

In the meantime, the left was busy dropping atomic bombs on Japan, putting Japanese Westerners in prison camps, fighting to keep their slaves, and latching to Jim Crow like a fungus. Anything else nomenpuss?

Side: Nah. Check Out My Lies.
1 point

double-speak

Yes yes...let's show some examples.

Nomenclature: religion is the problem in the world.

Bronto: Islam is a religion.

Nomenclature: You racist bigot! Religion means Christianity!

--

Nomenclature: we are antifascists.

Bronto: Islam is fascist per its own definition of itself.

Nomenclature: you racist bronto! By fascist I mean white people!

Bronto: Islam isn't a race. It's a religion.

Nomenclature: stop lying bronto! Islam is about being brown and oppressed!

Bronto: millions of Muslims aren't brown.

Nomenclature: quit twisting words bronto!

Bronto: And Islam is more Conservative than the Western right is. Your allying with them, then calling us fascists, misogynysts, homophobic, etc is illogical.

Nomenclature: Stop pointing out how far right they are. We mean whites when we say conservative.

Bronto: most conservatives in the world aren't white.

Nomenclature: stop bronto! This is about identity politics and picking tribes damn it!

Side: Nah. Check Out My Lies.
1 point

Nomenclature: Naziism is a right wing movement.

Bronto: The link you provided said he claimed Naziism was neither a left nor right wing movement.

Nomenclature: You're being dishonest bronto!

Bronto: It's your link...

Bronto: Hitler also claimed he was a Socialist.

Nomenclature: Yes, but he was a liar.

Bronto: His followers, the Nazis, didn't know that. So...they were following him thinking he was a Socialist...meaning they were socialists.

Nomenclature: Um what? I couldn't hear you. Hitler was a Christian.

Bronto: You just said he was a liar.

Nomenclature: about everything except being a Christian.

Bronto: His quotes about Christianity at the height of his power were anti Christian.

Nomenclature: And...Hitler was in a war against Communists!

Bronto: His allies were Communists. He also hated Jews...just like you. Tell me how you feel about Israel.

Bronto: He also held a monopoly on academia and the mainstream press...similar to the modern left.

Nomenclature: quit abusing words bronto!

Bronto: It's not my fault that you haven't mastered the English language...

Nomenclature: I'm in my safe space bronto.

Bronto: No, you're in your mom's ass right now gobbling her like a feedsack.

Nomenclature: I want you soooo bad right now.

Bronto: I know. Now who's your bronto? Go ahead, tell me.

Nomenclature: You are big boy. Now get off my sister and give me a turn.

Bronto: But she's your sister...

Nomenclature: But we can pretend....

Nomenclature's Sister: No Nomenclature. Your Hitler stache tickles my butt.

(Bronto quickly scampers on all fours away and into the weeds as to not be molested.)

(Nomenclature chases down Bronto. Bronto begins giving Nomenclature a noogie.)

Bronto:This isn't defense nom! This isn't defense! This is offense! Get ya some bronto offense! Stop arguing with the dictionary Nom!

(Bronto drags Nomenclature to the nearest bathroom and forces him to eat corn and peanuts.)

Nomenclature: mmmmm...peanut....

Peanut: mmmmmm...nomenclature...

(Strange noises and rabbed grinding sounds commence between peanut and Nomensnatch....)

Side: Nah. Check Out My Lies.
1 point

"Of all the posters here who promote right wing politics, not a single one of them is intellectually honest."

You consider me right wing, even going so far as to call me a Nazi, so it should be easy to substantiate your claim and demonstrate a time that I showed intellectual dishonesty. I'll wait.

Side: Nah. Check Out My Lies.
1 point

I'll wait.

I'm not trawling through your posting history looking for posts you might well have edited or deleted, but you certainly have demonstrated intellectual dishonesty in our past exchanges. One difference is that rather than continue to lie, you usually stop replying. It's rare that you spend hours trying to dig yourself out of your own grave, like many other posters here.

That said, I've also seen you blindly support the posts of notorious liars like Amarel and Bronto, simply because they happen to be on the right of a particular issue or debate.

Side: The Left Is Honest
WinstonC(1225) Disputed
1 point

"posts you might well have edited or deleted"

I've never deleted a post and have only edited posts immediately after posting, to rectify spelling or to make a point clearer.

"you certainly have demonstrated intellectual dishonesty in our past exchanges"

Yet you cannot bring a single instance to mind?

"One difference is that rather than continue to lie, you usually stop replying."

I stop replying once my point has been made abundantly clear, rather than endlessly repeat myself.

"I've also seen you blindly support the posts of notorious liars like Amarel and Bronto, simply because they happen to be on the right of a particular issue or debate."

I don't blindly support anyone or anything. I'm not aware of any time that Amarel has lied, perhaps you can enlighten me? Or will this be another unsubstantiated claim in a long list? As for Bronto, I don't recall the last time I stepped into a debate to support him. In any case, guilt by association is fallacious.

Side: Nah. Check Out My Lies.
0 points

The actual right, or the perceived right?

The actual right, conservatism, has values that are notably different from liberalism, but honest, and display some integrity - see William Buckley, George Will, Adam Smith, etc.

The perceived right has no comprehension of conservatism that isn't polluted in various ways, and considering that Trump is their hero - the man that built an empire of lies - what would come more natural?

These are not your father's conservatives. They definitely aren't my father's conservatives - he's a republican, and can't stand them.

Side: Nah. Check Out My Lies.
Rusticus(809) Clarified
2 points

@ EldonG - Sorry to parse words because I completely agree with you in the main but I take exception to your use of the phrase 'perceived right'. This new bizarro twisted version of conservatism is what it is, it's not just a perception, it's a reality.

I agree with you that true conservatives are horrified at the takeover by the tea party Alt-Right barbarians. In reality they're fascists and should be labeled as such but they cower behind the label of conservatism. William F. Buckley Jr. would be horrified by them and cross the street to avoid them or humiliate them in debate.

Any true conservative with a conscience like George Will has left them behind. As for Adam Smith, they don't know who Adam Smith was nor do they care.

Side: The Left Is Honest
0 points

With that caveat, I'll change positions. I rather expected to, even as I first posted.

Old-school conservatives I can disagree with and still respect. This modern gaggle, I have trouble with.

Edit: This was a "support", but came out against, so I downvoted myself.

Side: Nah. Check Out My Lies.
1 point

You're right. It's not my father's conservatism. The modern conservative looks like your father's liberalism. The right moved left, so the left moved? Further left.

Side: The Left Is Honest
EldonG(530) Disputed
1 point

Politics and politicians have moved right over the years, even as people moved left, but then, I'm honest.

Side: Nah. Check Out My Lies.