First, I don't think you can substantiate your opinion that the vast majority of rape cases are true. I don't think you can even guess at a percentage.

Second, due to the nature of rape, victims commonly say they made it all up, even when they didn't. They regret making the report.

Third, the example you cited makes for a slam dunk case if that man sues her accuser in civil court. Seeking compensation comenserate with damages in civil court is going to achieve a more just (harshe) outcome than simply applying a false report criminal charge (wherein the victim may not even be compensated).

I agree that a false accusation of rape is an outrage. It damages not only the victim of the accusation, but also the outlook for actual rape victims down the road. But unless you want a brand new law for this "special" kind of false report, the best response is still a civil suit. Otherwise the jail time remains on par with the misdemeanor of a regular false report.

What's up Nick and how you doing !So Nick says-" I don't think it should be under the circumstance that a woman loses a court case, but rather if the woman admits that it was a false accusation, or if it can be proven with substantial evidence."

Hey Nick you remember this-"The nation was stunned in 1987 by an African-American teenager’s accusation that she had been brutally gang raped by a group of white men, including a local prosecutor and a local police officer. Those accusations turned out to be an elaborate hoax.Eleven years after Tawana Brawley’s sensational story was disproved, former prosecutor Steven Pagones successfully sued Brawley, her attorneys and Rev. Al Sharpton who had gotten involved with the case for slander." That enough substantial evidence for you Nick ?

Hey Nick you remember this-"On the night of March 13, 2006,Crystal Mangum and another woman were hired by members of the Duke Lacrosse team to dance and strip at a house party. Early the next morning, she reported to Durham police that she had been sexually assaulted by some of the lacrosse players. The allegations riveted the nation and then the case fell apart amid a series of inconsistencies in accounts of the evening. Crystal Mangum lives on in the public consciousness as one of America’s most infamous rape accusers.

Hey Nick you know what they have in common is both of them are Black !

So Nick the vast majority of rape cases are not completely true !

Let's revisit the Rolling Stone article Nick -" A federal court jury decided that a Rolling Stone journalist defamed a former University of Virginia associate dean in a 2014 magazine article about sexual assault on campus that included a debunked account of a fraternity gang rape.

The 10-member jury concluded that the Rolling Stone reporter, Sabrina Rubin Erdely, was responsible for defamation, with actual malice, in the case brought by Nicole Eramo, a U-Va. administrator who oversaw sexual violence cases at the time of the article’s publication. The jury also found the magazine and its parent company, Wenner Media, responsible for defaming Eramo, who has said her life’s work helping sexual assault victims was devastated as a result of Rolling Stone’s article and its aftermath.

Nick says-"The only issue I see is that laws such as this in place may discourage women from admitting they made a case up."

Didn't discourage the Progressive Rag the Rolling Stone from making up a case now did it Nick !

Nick the Progressive it should be very telling to you that Progressives own false rape allegations and i exposed it for you !